Secondary Market Annuities: What They Are and How They Work
Secondary market annuities can offer above-market fixed income yields — but they come with illiquidity, legal complexity, and risks that most investors do not fully understand before committing. Here is a clear-eyed guide.
Understanding Secondary Market Annuities
A Secondary Market Annuity (SMA) is an existing income stream — originally created through a structured settlement, lottery payout, or deferred annuity — that the original recipient has chosen to sell in exchange for a lump sum of cash. When a buyer purchases that future payment stream, they typically do so at a discount to the total face value of the payments, and in return receive each scheduled payment as it comes due over the remaining term.
The most common origin of an SMA is a structured settlement from a personal injury lawsuit. The settlement winner may receive payments over 20 or more years but needs a large amount of cash immediately. They approach a factoring company, which purchases the future payment rights at a steep discount. That factoring company then offers the payment stream to investors at a markup — one that still represents a yield above most conventional fixed-income options.
SMAs can look attractive on paper, particularly when conventional annuity rates are moderate. But the complexity, illiquidity, and legal requirements involved mean they are not appropriate for most retirement savers. As Jason Zweig of the Wall Street Journal cautioned: “Even in the rare situations when they might make sense, you must proceed with extraordinary caution.”
Secondary Market Annuities are not new annuity products issued by an insurance company. They are the resale of an existing payment stream that was originally created for someone else — most often from a personal injury structured settlement.
You are buying the contractual right to receive a fixed series of future payments. Once the transaction closes, your capital is entirely illiquid for the full remaining term. There is no early exit, no free withdrawal provision, and no standard surrender charge period with a buyout option.
The yield advantage over a conventional annuity may be real — but so are the risks. Legal verification, carrier financial strength, and working with an advisor who specialises in SMA transactions are all mandatory, not optional.
How Secondary Market Annuities Are Created and Sold
SMAs pass through several hands before reaching an investor. Understanding each stage protects you from overpaying — and from buying an improperly transferred payment stream.
Original Settlement or Annuity Created
An insurance company issues a structured settlement annuity, lottery payment, or deferred annuity to an individual — the original annuitant. Payments are scheduled over a defined term, often monthly or annually for 10 to 30 years.
Original Recipient Sells to a Factoring Firm
The original recipient decides they need a lump sum today rather than waiting for future payments. They approach a factoring company, which purchases the rights to those future payments at a significant discount to the total face value — providing the seller with immediate cash.
Court Approval Is Obtained
For structured settlement transfers, a court must review and approve the transaction under the Structured Settlement Protection Act. This step is legally required and non-optional. A valid court order is the legal foundation of the entire SMA transaction. Without it, the transfer may be void.
Factoring Firm Sells to an Investor
The factoring firm then resells the payment stream to an investor — typically at a markup above the discount price they paid. The investor receives a yield that, after the markup, is still above most conventional fixed-income alternatives. The insurance company continues making payments directly to whoever holds the legal rights to the stream.
Pros and Cons of Secondary Market Annuities
Like any fixed-income investment, SMAs carry a distinct set of advantages and drawbacks. Know both before making any commitment.
Four Risks You Must Understand Completely
Secondary market annuities are not suitable for most investors. These are the risks that demand your full attention before any decision is made.
Financial Illiquidity for the Full Term
Unlike the person who originally sold their structured settlement, you — as the buyer — cannot sell your SMA if you encounter a financial emergency and need cash quickly. There is no free withdrawal provision, no surrender period with a buyout path, and no issuer standing behind a cancellation policy. Any capital placed in an SMA must be capital you can absolutely afford to have locked away for the complete remaining payment term.
Fixed Purchase Price You Cannot Negotiate
Secondary Market Annuities are sold at a fixed price determined by the factoring company. Unlike a conventional annuity where you determine the premium based on your retirement goals, an SMA comes with a preset price that may be far beyond what you should commit to a single illiquid position. A deal priced at $500,000 to receive $1,000,000 over 10 years is not inherently a good deal — the right question is whether you should concentrate that much illiquid capital in a single instrument at all.
Insurance Carrier Default Risk
Your payment stream is only as reliable as the insurance company that originally issued the annuity. Most SMA payment streams come from reputable carriers and receive state guaranty association protection — typically up to $100,000 to $500,000 per person per carrier, though limits vary by state. Before committing, verify the carrier’s financial strength ratings through A.M. Best, Moody’s, or Standard & Poor’s. Accept nothing below an A rating.
Court Approval Is Legally Required — and Must Be Verified
All Secondary Market Annuities involving structured settlements must pass through a formal court approval process under the Structured Settlement Protection Act before the transfer has legal standing. This is not optional. You and your advisor must confirm that the factoring company obtained a valid court order approving the transfer. If this step was not completed properly, the transfer may be void and your investment could be at risk — with little practical recourse.
Who Should — and Should Not — Consider an SMA
For most retirement savers, a conventional annuity from a top-rated carrier is a more appropriate starting point. SMAs occupy a narrow niche suited to specific investor profiles.
Have Substantial Liquid Assets Outside the SMA
The invested amount represents a small fraction of your total liquid net worth. You have fully funded emergency reserves and are not relying on SMA payments as your primary retirement income.
Are a Sophisticated Investor Comfortable With Complexity
You understand fixed-income instruments, have reviewed the court approval documentation, verified the carrier financial strength, and have engaged an attorney or advisor who specialises in SMA transactions.
Want Predictable Fixed Income Beyond What Bonds or CDs Offer
You are seeking a higher fixed yield than conventional instruments provide, you do not need access to the principal during the term, and the payment schedule aligns with your income needs.
Can Afford to Have Capital Locked Away for the Full Term
You have no foreseeable need for the invested capital before the payment stream concludes — whether that is 5, 10, or 20 years — and have confirmed this with a comprehensive financial plan.
Are Investing Your Core Retirement Savings
If the SMA investment represents a significant share of your retirement assets, the illiquidity alone makes it an inappropriate choice. A conventional annuity provides comparable safety with far greater flexibility and regulatory oversight.
May Need Access to the Capital Before the Term Ends
Medical costs, home repairs, family obligations, or unexpected life changes may require funds you cannot foresee today. With an SMA, you have no access to the principal under any circumstances once the transfer is complete.
Are Not Working With a Specialist Advisor or Attorney
The legal documentation involved in an SMA transaction — court orders, assignment paperwork, carrier verification — requires specialised knowledge. A general financial planner or independent broker without SMA experience is not sufficient oversight for this type of transaction.
Have Not Fully Funded Other Retirement Vehicles First
If your IRA, 401(k), or other registered retirement plans are not yet maximised, an SMA is not the right next step. Tax-advantaged vehicles should always be funded first before considering alternative fixed-income products of this complexity.
Frequently Asked Questions
1 What yield can I actually expect from a Secondary Market Annuity? ▼
SMA yields vary significantly based on the remaining payment term, the creditworthiness of the underlying carrier, and current market conditions. Because the factoring firm purchased the original payment stream at a steep discount and you are paying a markup above that, the net yield to the investor is typically higher than conventional fixed annuities or comparable bonds — but meaningfully lower than the raw “discount” number quoted by sellers would suggest.
Always ask for a written breakdown of the internal rate of return (IRR) on your specific proposed deal, accounting for your purchase price and the full scheduled payment stream. Compare that figure against what a top-rated insurer will offer on a new conventional fixed annuity before committing.
2 Can a lifetime annuity be sold as a Secondary Market Annuity? ▼
No. Immediate lifetime annuities — where payments are tied to the lifespan of the original annuitant — cannot be sold as Secondary Market Annuities because the payment stream cannot be legally separated from the life of the person it is based on. Only payment streams with a fixed remaining term — period-certain or term-certain annuities, structured settlements with a defined schedule, and certain deferred annuities — can be transferred on the secondary market. This is an important distinction, as life-contingent payments have no ascertainable end date and therefore no calculable purchase price.
3 What happens to my SMA if the insurance company becomes insolvent? ▼
State guaranty associations provide a backstop for annuity contracts issued by insolvent carriers, but the protection limits vary by state — typically $100,000 to $500,000 per person per company. If you are investing more than the guaranty limit in a single SMA from one carrier, the excess amount is unsecured carrier risk with no backstop protection.
This is one of the most important reasons to verify the issuing carrier’s financial strength ratings before purchasing any SMA, and to avoid concentrating large sums in a single deal with a single insurer. Carriers rated A or above by A.M. Best have historically demonstrated strong claims-paying ability, but no rating is a guarantee.
4 Can I hold a Secondary Market Annuity inside an IRA or retirement account? ▼
In some cases yes, but the structure is complex. Holding an SMA inside an IRA requires a self-directed IRA with a custodian that accepts non-traditional assets. Not all custodians do, and fees for self-directed IRA administration can reduce the yield advantage of the SMA.
Additionally, the tax deferral benefit of an IRA may offer limited value for an SMA, since the income is already a contractual fixed obligation rather than a growing pool of capital. Combining an SMA with a self-directed IRA introduces additional layers of compliance and documentation. Speak with both a tax advisor and an SMA-specialist attorney before pursuing this structure.
5 How do I verify that the court approval was completed correctly? ▼
Ask the factoring firm or broker selling the SMA to provide a certified copy of the court order approving the transfer. This document should identify the transferor (the original settlement recipient), the transferee (the factoring firm), the scheduled payment stream, and the judge’s authorisation. The order must be from a court with jurisdiction over the original settlement.
Before signing anything, have an attorney with experience in structured settlement transactions review the court order and all supporting documentation. The cost of that legal review is minimal compared to the size of the investment and the consequence of discovering a defective transfer after the fact.
6 How does a Secondary Market Annuity compare to buying a conventional fixed annuity? ▼
A conventional fixed annuity is a new contract issued directly between you and an insurance company. You work with a licensed advisor to determine the right premium amount, payment term, and payout structure for your retirement goals. You benefit from regulatory protections, state insurance oversight, and in many cases the ability to make limited free withdrawals.
An SMA is a pre-existing payment stream with a fixed price and zero flexibility after purchase. The yield may be higher, but the trade-offs — complete illiquidity, legal complexity, preset deal size, and the absence of any issuer relationship — are significant. For most people researching retirement income, a conventional fixed annuity from a top-rated carrier is the more appropriate starting point. If you are interested in comparing current rates, our Compare Annuity Rates tool connects you with licensed advisors at no obligation.
Related Resources
Annuity Guide
Our complete guide to annuities — types, benefits, costs, and how to choose the right product for your retirement plan.
Read the guide → Advanced ReadingBuying Secondary Market Annuities
A deeper dive into the purchasing process, due diligence checklist, and what questions to ask before you commit to an SMA transaction.
Read the article → Take ActionCompare Annuity Rates
See current rates from top-rated carriers. A free, no-obligation report from licensed advisors — no commitment required.
Compare rates → Annuity TypesFixed Annuities Explained
How conventional fixed annuities provide a guaranteed rate of return — with the regulatory protections and flexibility that SMAs do not offer.
Learn more →Ready to Explore Annuity Options?
Before pursuing secondary market annuities, compare what top-rated carriers are offering today. A licensed advisor can walk you through your options — fixed, indexed, and immediate — at no cost and no obligation.